Is Colby Keller The Best Gay Porn Star Of 2014?

Posted October 20, 2014 by with 34 comments

colby keller gay porn

It’s that time of year again: For the second year in a row, Str8UpGayPorn presents the 2nd Annual Str8ie Awards for 2014′s Best Gay Porn Star!

Last year’s winner was Connor Kline (who immediately retired right after winning—I hope this award isn’t cursed!), so who will take home the gay porn industry’s most prestigious trophy this year? It’s 100% up to you. Like last year, the Str8ie winner will be determined solely by fan voting, and like last year, there will be 10 nominees. Nominee #1 was Ryan Rose, and today I can reveal nominee #2: Colby Keller!

tumblr_navdm7qcT21toke85o1_1280

Colby Keller is the second nominee in the Str8ie Awards contest for 2014′s Best Gay Porn Star, but stay tuned, because eight more gay porn star nominees will be unveiled as we head towards the end of the year. Then, all 10 will face off in one round of fan voting to determine 2014′s Best Gay Porn Star.

tumblr_n8oijv7xa61shagoro1_500

Here is a look back at nominee #2, Colby Keller, in some of his best work from 2014. Through his various projects and performances this year, Colby cemented his status not just as a gay porn legend, but also as a cultural icon for gay men, hipsters, women, and anyone else who was paying attention to sexuality in 2014. Somebody even made a merman out of him, for Christ’s sake.

tumblr_n9g5nsBVIZ1rw3pgqo4_500As a top, Colby Keller has fucked his scene partners with incredible intensity. In fact, many of his co-stars have gone on to reveal that being fucked by Colby Keller was the best sexual experience they’d ever had.

tumblr_n9jogbzH8t1rw3pgqo1_500tumblr_ncc8r03sT81te42yzo1_500Of course, Colby has done plenty of bottoming, too…

tumblr_nc92wr88Ed1te42yzo1_400tumblr_n9g5nsBVIZ1rw3pgqo6_500

But perhaps the one thing people think of when they think of Colby Keller is cum. Lots of cum.

Here’s Colby giving Luke Adams’ face a fresh coat of white paint (via Men.com):

tumblr_naxabzcuCn1qb18qmo1_400As much as he likes to give, Colby Keller isn’t afraid to receive…

colbyjarec1colbyjarec2colbyjarec3
[Randy Blue: Jarec Wentworth Cums In Colby Keller’s Mouth]

And even though the year isn’t over yet, the best cum shot of 2014 was already delivered last month. It was when Colby Keller unleashed the thickest, creamiest, most volcanic load of 2014 directly onto Seth Santoro’s face, and it was the cum shot heard ’round the world:

colbyseth1colbyseth2

colbyseth3colbyseth4
Colby-Keller-Seth-Santoro_0206tumblr_nbtd61eKjn1trxwgdo1_400[CockyBoys: Colby Keller Fucks Seth Santoro]

Is Colby Keller 2014′s Best Gay Porn Star?

LastCallDMH150002

Colby Keller fucks Luke Adams in “Last Call” on Men.com:

[Men.com Colby Keller Fucks Luke Adams]

[CockyBoys: Colby Keller Filmography]
[Randy Blue: Colby Keller Filmography]
[Men.com: Colby Keller Filmography]

 

  • Alan Keddie

    Giflicious! Colby is hot when his hair is short. I’d take him with tidy, short facial hair but not with the hobo look. I like that he tops as well as he bottoms. He stays ROCK hard when getting fucked and is a great power top too.

    • Glorfindel

      Agree totally. Trim the beard.

  • Dewitt2it

    Yes. Just yes.

  • McM.

    Have to, and hate to, admit Colby Keller’s performances aren’t as good as his Raging Stallion days.

    But he’s still one of my faves.

  • robirob

    Colby Keller is a great pornstar, because he has a great attitude and is a great performer. It’s also a plus that he isn’t a hot mess with a ton of police arrests and mug shots under his belt.

  • NG212

    He very well might be. Sexy as hell, and he knows how to *perform.*

  • Todd

    Colby might be my choice. Overall hot guy and great versatile performer. He may end up with my vote. Agree I like the more cleaned up version of Colby. …. When he starts heading into James Jameson territory ….eh, not so much

  • I don’t actively seek out clips with him very often for some reason, but he is hot (“clean” -and- “hobo”) and a good performer, I’ll give him that. I have no problem with the nomination.

  • Marcelinha Ferreira

    NO

    • Joey

      Dale Cooper, is dat chu?

      • gwminsd

        ROFLMPO

  • Alan Keddie

    And let’s not forget: Colby is actually gay.

  • moondoggy

    This is my biggest “not bareback” regret of all time, maybe. If he ever finally shed the condom, the next time we see Jenifer Lewis passing out, she’ll be landing on top of my already unconscious body.

    On looks alone, Colby is all around one of the most attractive men I think I’ve ever seen. The grungier he looks sometimes, the more it calls attention to the impossibility of marring his looks, though if he ever got huge tattoos, that might nix it for me.

  • ThatsEnoughGravy

    I’m going to say yes. I’ve never seen him turn in a bad performance.

  • andrew

    Maybe in the top 10, but nowhere near #1.

  • Zealot

    Mark my ballot “YES” right now!

  • GN

    I would love to eat his asshole….

  • pje821

    Even though he’s been around awhile I never tire of him, which is more than I can say for a lot of often-seen porn actors. Plus, his lack of tattoos and always-hot loads push him to the front of the line.

  • yeah yeah

    He is HOT!

  • Johnny

    I have never understood the attraction to Colby Keller. He does absolutely nothing for me.

    • BLACKjackHAMMER

      Just as U cannot understand the attraction I cannot understand all the hate !!!

      • Johnny

        I don’t hate. I just don’t get. He’s not ugly. I’m not attacking. I just don’t get why some guys are so crazy for him. Reminds me of guys who go nuts for Evan Peters on AHS. He’s not bad looking, but the way some people carry on about him, you’d think he was supermodel-hot. He’s just a decent enough looking white boy.

    • Alan Keddie

      Ditto the attraction to that Cheryl Tweedy Cole Fernandez whatever her name is.

  • sxg

    Perhaps in previous years yes, but for me I found him to be uninteresting this year. It probably has nothing to do with his performance, but more on his trashy look. Hated the pony tail shit he had, and he does not look all that hot with with a huge beard. James Jamesson carried his much better.

    I hope to see Tanner on here! So far he’s one of the ones I would definitely vote for if he was nominated!

  • Alan Keddie

    TAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANNER ftw

  • I love the Gabriel Clark/Colby Keller gif.

    • Alan Keddie

      Seconded

  • MisterGnome

    And rimming. He seems to really enjoy it, and I could endlessly watch him eating an ass!

  • Casey Scott

    He’s definitely up there! And he actually brought something resembling a performance out of Jake Wilder. That’s magic!

  • Nickolas

    I’m obsessed with cum, and he has it in droves. I’d swallow his load any day.

  • John

    Love the way he gets fucked….he is definitely at the top of the list

  • Joey

    God, Colby is such a curious case. Has anyone had such a hot improvement on their physical body the way he has in the last couple years? His definition is pretty amazing from even just last year. And yet, I only think he truly shines when he’s on full display in those awesome Cockyboys scenes. His scene partners range from ugh to WOW constantly. And in 2014, not having a mugshot wall of shame, not being a flaming hot mess and not being a total jackass on twitter only adds to the appeal. He’s very sexy but totally sabotages it by going overboard with that fuckin beard he’s so clearly proud of. He’s managed to also have crossover appeal with women too so that’s a first. So curious.

    If we’re judging based on performance alone, I can’t think of anyone else who puts in 100% each time tho.

  • Super Marco Manuel

    Colby Keller is not the best gay porn star.But,he is not the worst either.He is good.Not great.

    Theres also better looking men that Colby in gay porn.Too bad Colby had the have that fucking beard most of the year.Colby looks way better without beard.

    Colby did what is a big trend with gay porn stars.Which is asking for money for a fund.In exchange he would get his beard shaved.He did have his money.So,he shaved his beard.But only for a short time.Because as soon his beard grown,he kept it.So,his asking for money then being shaves was a waste.Gay men expected Colby to be shaved for good.But,Colby is already back with a beard.

    Colby really seems to like his beard.You might have to deal with his beard for a long time.It doesnt look like he will get rid of his beard anytime soon.He really should shave his beard.Really!

    • gwminsd

      GO SHAVE YOU PUSSY men have beards